[Maria-discuss] Differences between MariaDB packages
Hello, I recently discovered a bug in my MariaDB deployment process. I have two Ansible tasks that respectively add the downloads.mariadb.org Debian repo, and install mariadb-server-10.*. I forgot to add 'update_cache: yes' to the repo add task, so incidentally mariadb-server-10.* was actually installed from the Debian repo. I have seen the following differences between the mariadb-server-10.* packages: - Packages from Debian repo only come with the 'root@localhost' user. Packages from MariaDB repo come with the users 'root@localhost', 'root@::1' and 'root@127.0.0.1'. - Packages from Debian repo don't come with 'debian-sys-maint@localhost' user. Instead, the 'root' user is used in /etc/mysql/debian.cnf - Packages from Debian repo use DebianAlternatives for my.cnf. Packages from MariaDB repo also come with a more advanced my.cnf, e.g. 'bind-address = 127.0.0.1' is set - not being able to remotely connect is how I discovered this bug on my side. - Packages from MariaDB repo come with package configuration (specifically: setting root password). Q: I'm wondering if anyone has a more complete list of differences between these packages (the above is just what I've observed from fixing issues due to this bug). I don't know if the Debian maintainers for this package branch off a package by MariaDB, so I posted this here, but please let me know if I would be better off posting this on a Debian mailing list. TIA. With kind regards, William Edwards
Hello! The sources for Debian packaging in Debian and Ubuntu are in the debian/ directory at https://github.com/MariaDB/server/tree/10.5/debian The sources for Debian packaging in MariaDB.org repositories are in the debian/ directory https://github.com/MariaDB/server/tree/10.5/debian Currently the differences in 10.5 for these two are fairly small. The older version you are looking at, the bigger are the differences. Your message does not mention what version you were looking at. There is no single place where the differences would be documented, but you can see in the sources the specific details you are interested in. As a general rule of thumb, use as recent versions of MariaDB as possible and you will have less issues of both packaging and other bugs. - Otto
Hi, William! You, likely, mean mariadb-server-10.2 or mariadb-server-10.3. This was a transitional period, in a sense. Debian packages have switched to the unix_socket authentication and MariaDB packages haven't. Since 10.4 both Debian and MariaDB packages use unix_socket authentication and a passwordless root account. Before 10.2 (?) both Debian and MariaDB packages had debian-sys-maint user and three root accounts with a password. Regards, Sergei VP of MariaDB Server Engineering and security@mariadb.org On Jun 26, William Edwards wrote:
Hello,
I recently discovered a bug in my MariaDB deployment process. I have two Ansible tasks that respectively add the downloads.mariadb.org Debian repo, and install mariadb-server-10.*. I forgot to add 'update_cache: yes' to the repo add task, so incidentally mariadb-server-10.* was actually installed from the Debian repo. I have seen the following differences between the mariadb-server-10.* packages:
- Packages from Debian repo only come with the 'root@localhost' user. Packages from MariaDB repo come with the users 'root@localhost', 'root@::1' and 'root@127.0.0.1'. - Packages from Debian repo don't come with 'debian-sys-maint@localhost' user. Instead, the 'root' user is used in /etc/mysql/debian.cnf - Packages from Debian repo use DebianAlternatives for my.cnf. Packages from MariaDB repo also come with a more advanced my.cnf, e.g. 'bind-address = 127.0.0.1' is set - not being able to remotely connect is how I discovered this bug on my side. - Packages from MariaDB repo come with package configuration (specifically: setting root password).
Q: I'm wondering if anyone has a more complete list of differences between these packages (the above is just what I've observed from fixing issues due to this bug).
I don't know if the Debian maintainers for this package branch off a package by MariaDB, so I posted this here, but please let me know if I would be better off posting this on a Debian mailing list.
participants (3)
-
Otto Kekäläinen -
Sergei Golubchik -
William Edwards